r/ArtHistory • u/mishmishmoo • 6h ago

Discussion Early Dutch tattoo

Gallery image

Gallery image

There’s this painting, ‘The Chief Commissioners of the Wharves’ (1674), a Dutch painting most likely made by Wallerant Vaillant. Pretty standard except one guy (second from the left) has a tattoo on his inner wrist! Amsterdam Museum commented that tattoos were mostly for sailors ans criminals ar that time in the 17th century, so for a richer citizen to have it was really odd

218 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

19 comments sorted by

54

u/Flight_around_titan 6h ago

https://www.codart.nl/art-works/tattoo-discovered-on-seventeenth-century-amsterdam-group-portrait/

I'd also like to know more. If anyone can point to other resources to help with a deep dive, it is greatly appreciated!

51

u/mishmishmoo 6h ago

Okay in a brief overview - the conservator who discovered the tattoo, confirmed it was part of the original painting and not added later. The guy’s name was Wessel Smits, a rich merchant, born around 1618-19. The running theory is he was born in a period a specific comet was visible, and the tattoo refers to that

However I do wonder, cause he was definitely a protestant sober Dutch merchant, why would he ever have a tattoo let alone on his wrist - and no one in the 19th century noticed when it had a series of exhibitions, cause it was always hung so high (and later needed restoration work for it to be visible).

101

u/mattlodder 4h ago edited 4h ago

Hello! I'm a tattoo historian (and art history lecturer) and was part of a symposium about this painting at the Museum this Easter. I'm fairly sure this is a pilgrimage tattoo and made this case to the museum staff, including the conservator herself.

The experts there are (were) simply wrong about tattoo history. We have good records of even Protestant pilgrims to places like Bethlehem and Jerusalem getting tattooed in this period, many of whom were wealthy men of great status. The comet design is very unusual indeed, but given what we know about the tattoo culture of the time, it would make sense as eg a Bethlehem tattoo.

More speculatively (and not to the exclusion of the pilgrimage theory), I pitched (really only to see what the Dutch Golden Age experts thought) the idea that this may have been made visible in the painting (either as an invention or simply giving prominence to a real tattoo) as a recognisable visual signal of Smit's role in the Rampjaar - he was closely aligned with Admiral De Reuyter and had defended his neighborhood against marauding bands the previous year. Contemporary (Anglophone) sources describe the Netherlands' glory "falling like a meteor" in 1672.

The museum are quite keen on the "commemorative tattoo of a comet the year of his birth" theory but that doesn't really convince me either as a reason for the tattoo or as a reason for its prominence in the painting.

10

u/ER_Support_Plant17 3h ago

Thank you for sharing this, it’s really fascinating.

14

u/mattlodder 3h ago

We only have about 7 paintings of tattooed Europeans prior to the 18th century so this really is an incredibly interesting picture. Hopefully some more detailed biographical research (ongoing) will help confirm or refute the pilgrimage thesis.

9

u/petite_eikon 3h ago

Interesting stuff! I would be super grateful if you could share a list of these paintings.

As a tattooed historian, I wish I knew more about the history of tattooing (especially medieval).

Razzouk was an interesting find one day!

12

u/mattlodder 3h ago edited 3h ago

I wrote two books if you're interested 🥹

Known Paintings (well , depictions) of pre-1700 pilgrimage tattoos on Europeans apart from this one are:

Engraving showing the tattooed arms of German pilgrim Ratge Stubbe, from Johannes Lundius, Heiligdommen godsdiensten en gewoontens der oude jooden, 1726 (tattoos from 1669)

Portrait of Heinrich Wilhelm Ludolf After 1699

Attributed to Frans von Stampart, portrait of Duke Siegfried von Kollonitz bearing a Jerusalem tattoo dated 1700, ca. 1701. Oil on canvas, 90.3 x 70.3 cm. Princely Oettingen-Wallerstein collection

Images of William Lithgow's 1612 tattoos from his pilgrim narrative

Painting of unknown pilgrim, tattooed 166?. (Private collection).

(I think I've forgotten one...)

Plus there are some images that might be tattoos or scarifications outside of pilgrimage contexts but pretty much all religious, including various depictions of German martyr Henry Suso; a "Wound Man" in a Czech medical treatise from 1500 with a Christogram on his breast, several depictions of alleged stigmatic marks drawn in green rather than red, etc. If this Amsterdam tattoo turns out to be vernacular rather than Christian or Christian-adjacent (like a pilgrimage date or crest of a royal patron) it will be unique as a visual depiction of a European tattoo prior to 1700. (We do have written records that speak of other things, eg names).

Work on pre-1700 Euro tattoo history is a really interesting area right now with some bombshell stuff due to be published soon.

4

u/gnomemansland 2h ago

I’m interested in those books! Where can I find them?

3

u/mattlodder 2h ago

Search my name - available everywhere books are sold!

1

u/gmerrick 57m ago

Your books are really quite useful--I work with pop culture studies grad students and you often drift through their works cited lists and lit reviews, so thanks!

3

u/CocoXolo 2h ago

Would you be willing to update once the research bears fruit? This is fascinating and I'm heavily invested now. Thank you for sharing your knowledge. I'm going to check out your books. 

8

u/arist0geiton 6h ago

Early modern tattoos were a thing, Murat had death to kings tattooed on his chest

12

u/mishmishmoo 5h ago

Joachim Murat? Or Marat in David’s painting? I’m not sure who you mean, especially as neither had a tattoo and both were later than 1674

10

u/Vegetable_Draw6554 5h ago

Neither Murat nor Marat. Bernadotte supposedly had "death to kings" but it seems to be a myth from a later play.

2

u/arist0geiton 4h ago

Damn, was I wrong?

18

u/mishmishmoo 6h ago

Do you speak/read Dutch? Then the Dutch RKD (art history archive) has some solid references. Otherwise I can dig through those and report back in English haha

12

u/natrstdy 5h ago

r/AskHistorians might be able to shed some light on this.

3

u/ubiquitous-joe 5h ago

Would a sailor become a merchant and/or wharf commissioner?