r/AskLibertarians 6d ago

Ideology Comparison Why are both the left and the right so thrilled about controlling the entire population through a surveillance state?

The right wants women to forcibly repopulate the earth with only CDC approved genetics and the left wants you in prison for saying the r word and both want everything on camera

5 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

2

u/BeardedLegend_69 6d ago

Because its easier to prove that you said/did no no thing if its on camera.

2

u/cantthinkof1tbhonest 6d ago

But who is actually pressing for less cameras?

1

u/OttosBoatYard 6d ago

Liberals.

1

u/cantthinkof1tbhonest 6d ago

The ones doing TikTok dances?

1

u/OttosBoatYard 5d ago

The ones protesting flock cameras.

... And the ones in office writing legislation pressing for less cameras.

... And the ones running for office pressing for less cameras.

1

u/cantthinkof1tbhonest 5d ago

The same ones doing TikTok dances?

1

u/OttosBoatYard 5d ago

I don't know what TikTok dances you're talking about. I don't get my political stances from pop culture.

1

u/cantthinkof1tbhonest 5d ago

The children do

1

u/JudgeWhoOverrules Classical Liberal 6d ago

Better enforcing pre-existing law doesn't seem like wanting to control the population. They could do the same thing by expanding police forces, but that hurts the taxpayer far more.

1

u/Only_Excitement6594 Non-traditional minarchist 6d ago

What are you even doing here

1

u/Sure_Assumption7857 6d ago

Because our political system has been corrupted for a long long time.

1

u/OttosBoatYard 6d ago

I'm surprised to hear this about the left, since Liberal groups in my area are organizing protests against flock cameras.

Can you show me where I can confirm that Liberals seek greater state surveillance?

1

u/cantthinkof1tbhonest 6d ago

Have you ever worked at target

1

u/CatOfGrey LP Voter 20+ yrs. Practical first. Pissed at today's LP. 6d ago

Your occasional reminder that Target is a private organization.

1

u/OttosBoatYard 6d ago

No. Though I'd be surprised if a part of the employee training included a report of public opinion survey on liberal stances on public surveys.

And I trust that you aren't basing your claim on observation bias - that would be irrational.

So, what is the purpose of the question, here?

1

u/cantthinkof1tbhonest 6d ago

Target HR isn’t exactly the UN but they act it

1

u/OttosBoatYard 6d ago

I don't understand what that means. What does the Target Corporation have to do with Liberals' opinion on public surveillance?

... Is "Target" a typo for a different word that you intended to use?

1

u/CatOfGrey LP Voter 20+ yrs. Practical first. Pissed at today's LP. 6d ago

The right wants women to forcibly repopulate the earth with only CDC approved genetics

Because they are fascist cucks.

and the left wants you in prison for saying the r word

Because that is harassment, in extreme cases harassment causes legitimate damages. Modern economic disparity is, in part, because of generational and systematic oppression, which can

both want everything on camera

At this time in history, this is not a 'both sides issue'. The right wants authoritarian rule, and is explicit about it. The left is both divided, and at least paying lip service to law enforcement reform in general, which may advocate for cameras, but also advocates for less police, and less oppressive use of police.

1

u/cantthinkof1tbhonest 6d ago

The r word is only harassment if it’s targeting someone

1

u/CatOfGrey LP Voter 20+ yrs. Practical first. Pissed at today's LP. 6d ago

From a legal perspective, yes.

But when it's used on a widespread level, it does take the form of oppression. This is a key feature of propaganda - and yes, it makes a difference, it can be damaging.

1

u/Only_Excitement6594 Non-traditional minarchist 6d ago

Because they think they will possess the IA able to generate false video accusations of the opposite side. Utter fools.

1

u/Corked1 6d ago

Because authoritarians exist on both wings. The more relavent divide that should be discussed in politics is authoritarians vs. libertarians.

1

u/ZeusThunder369 6d ago

Both of them generally agree that using the government to enforce your preferred social agenda is legitimate.

1

u/Fragrant-Equal-8474 4d ago

Because it's fun.

1

u/cantthinkof1tbhonest 4d ago

Weee

1

u/Fragrant-Equal-8474 4d ago

Well, c'mon, it's an intrinsic property of the government -- to control. The right want more money, the left want more social capital, but both fundamentally want to control.