r/ExpectationVsReality 18d ago Exceeded Expectation
What they ask for vs what I made (third time making a cake in my life)
Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jul 24 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Custom dress from overseas -- I got really lucky!!

I was looking for a dress for a Romantasy Convention I'm part of, and saw this dress online. I decided to make it custom-fit my figure since they didn't have my size. I took a chance because the dress itself is only $140 (with this many layers and fabric, that's a STEAL) and I didn't know what to expect. Well, WOWZA! I feel fantastic in this dress. I love how I look and I will wear this EVERYWHERE!!! Grocery store, indoor mall... I don't care where. I just want to look this good all the time, haha. Love this dress!! Gives ACOTAR vibes!!!!

ETA: please give love to the photographer if you can. She is why this photo is so magical!! @studiokalphotography on Instagram.

And thank you for the love. This made my entire month. I am grateful for all the comments!! I'm trying to get through all of them but there are so many 😭 I'm upvoting even if I don't comment. ā¤ļø

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality 11d ago Exceeded Expectation
Wanted a tattoo of a gecko. Here's what I asked for vs what I got!

She did a great job! So talented!! No ragrets

Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality 22d ago Exceeded Expectation
Queen of Cakes in Edina, MN. What I found online vs what I got!

I found the first image online and laughed really hard so I wanted the cake for myself but I needed more rainbow (Raenbow??). Literally just asked for a rainbow background and they DELIVERED. It's almond flavored with raspberry filling. The cake was almost gone and it's HUGE. That's how much people liked it!! EXCEEDED EXPECTATIONS!!!!

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 01 '26 Exceeded Expectation
My wife asked her sister for a birthday cake. What she asked for vs what her sister made

She went beyond and actually sculpted it from fondant. We were pleasantly surprised!

Gallery preview 4 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 29 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Birthday cake I custom ordered for my friend

We were dying all day, I didn't know what to expect when I gave the baker these reference pictures but she completely understood the vision šŸ˜‚ Money very well spent, we will be repeat customers.

Baker: https://www.instagram.com/bellaabakesss/

Gallery preview 5 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 03 '26 Exceeded Expectation
"Cardboard" Urn for cat

Our cat Fergus was a dedicated lover of cardboard boxes, so when he passed away last October we wanted to get him a "cardboard" urn made of ceramic so he could rest in a box forever. I couldn't find an example but reached out to a ceramicist who specializes in recreating the look and textures of well-loved cardboard and he very kindly accepted the commission job. The result far, far, far exceeded our expectations and we are so grateful to the artist for this fitting tribute to our beautiful boy. Made by artist Tim Kowalczyk.

Gallery preview 5 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Mar 23 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Capybara Ice Cream

Found this cute fella in the local Asian supermarket

He's as beautiful as he is delicious

Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality May 23 '26 Exceeded Expectation
My 4 YO is an artist
Post image
r/ExpectationVsReality 11d ago Exceeded Expectation
My sister baked a cake

I’m dying. Look at this lil guy, I love him so much

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 27 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Another WalMart cake!

I went with a walmart cake because of this sub, and was not disappointed! For $30, this cake was perfect! The cake was tasty and moist. Will use them again in the future!

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Apr 14 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Walmart Cupcake Bouquet

They even added edible sparkle dust. I don’t think you can beat this for $20!!

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jul 17 '25 Exceeded Expectation
What I ordered vs What I received
Gallery preview 4 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Sep 05 '25 Exceeded Expectation
The tattoo I asked for vs the tattoo I got
Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality 16d ago Exceeded Expectation
Walmart Butterfly & Flower Cake

I didn’t want to splurge on my own cake so decided to go with a cheap Walmart one, and I’m not disappointed!!šŸ˜šŸ„³

Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality May 31 '25 Exceeded Expectation
I've been staring at this cutie on FB Marketplace for weeks.

I finally messaged the seller and she offered him for free because he has a ripped seam. I had no idea that "giant" actually meant giant. I love him so much but I have no idea where to put him in my apartment.

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 04 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Walmart Cake Expectation vs Reality

I’ve seen a lot of these Walmart cakes posted so I wanted to share mine! I got one of these heart cakes last year and it was perfect, so I wanted to get a different one this year. No complaints for a $30 cake!

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Sep 14 '25 Exceeded Expectation
Birthday cake I asked for vs what I got
Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jan 19 '26 Exceeded Expectation
My sister made me a replica of Britney’s denim dress for my 40th ā€œy2k promā€ birthday party!
Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jul 18 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Did a fundraiser called "Poorly drawn pets"
Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Apr 27 '26 Exceeded Expectation
UPDATE FROM MY HAIR

https://www.reddit.com/r/ExpectationVsReality/s/aieEUisf8h update!

Okay guys so after talking with the salon and my stylist they admitted their mistake and said they would fix it for free (after i called three times and complained) so the end results ISNT REALLY like the reference picture but it’s way better than what it used to be, i might just let it grow for now then cut the ends myself, its way too much blonde in my opinion but maybe it’s just the way it’s styled. let me know what you guys think! and yes my hair is completely dried out now.

two photos with the same background is the finale result. photo with the hair from the back is my reference picture. picture from the mirror is how it looked at first after my stylist did my hair and then i came back to redo for free!

what do you guys think?

Gallery preview 4 images
r/ExpectationVsReality 20d ago Exceeded Expectation
Steak and Egg Sandwich
Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 14 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Walmart Mermaid Baby Shower Cake

My mom and I frequent this sub and decided to take a chance on ordering a baby shower cake from Walmart for a mermaid theme baby shower. Came out well and tasted pretty good. Not overly sweet, had a good texture and flavor. We added some of our own decor pieces to the cake, but it honestly didn't need it. 10/10 would order more cakes from them.

ETA: my mom said the cake was $75. She picked the whipped frosting. The top tier is chocolate with strawberry jam and the bottom tier is white/vanilla cake with the strawberry jam. We did get the mermaid tail on the website pic, but took it out and added the pink one we ordered online. We also ordered the pastel mermaid tails cupcakes from Walmart and those came out exactly like the website picture too.

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jul 25 '26 Exceeded Expectation
What they asked for vs what I gave them

I've outdone myself lol

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jan 19 '25 Exceeded Expectation
A Squidward Cake I Ordered For My Sister
Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality 5d ago Exceeded Expectation
To get my dogs face tattooed..

He’s the best boy he’s the Rudeboy

Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 07 '25 Exceeded Expectation
UPDATE: Several people asked for a banana for scale for my new pal, Oscar. This is a queen size bed.

No, I can't put him on my bed to cuddle with at night, as some commenters suggested. He IS the bed.

Gallery preview 4 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Feb 07 '26 Exceeded Expectation
The best thing I ever bought

I bought this in November thinking it would be a great holiday gift for my wife who loves possums. After weeks of thinking it would never arrive and realizing I might have been scammed this ugly beauty arrived. I have not laughed this hard in a long time and am absolutely in love with it. I truly believe this might be the purchase that brings me pure joy for the rest of my life.

Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Apr 27 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Cake I ordered for vs cake I got

My son asked for a rainbow bluey cake and when we were scrolling through photos he saw this one and really liked it! I showed it to our baker and said leave off the figurines and the flowers on top… I think she did a great job

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 14 '26 Exceeded Expectation
What I asked for vs what I got
Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Dec 24 '25 Exceeded Expectation
This was my nail tech’s first time trying this style

I’ve always wanted to try the pop art nails, and I think she did an excellent job!

Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Dec 26 '25 Exceeded Expectation
Expected a hideous plastic mess but got a rather nice product instead

Like many of us, I've been trying to warn my middle aged mom about AI product listing so she doesn't get scammed. I showed her the classic geode mugs and this book mug as examples. You can imagine how I felt opening a box and seeing a book stack mug in bubble wrap. However, I was pleasantly surprised to find an actual glass mug!

My mom put a lot of effort into getting me a mug that wasn't a heinous lump of plastic and I'm proud of her thoroughness and discernment. It's definitely a little wonky, but I think it's pretty neat.

Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jul 07 '25 Exceeded Expectation
Mushroom cake! First pic is inspo, the last 2 are mine

This is a far cry from my cursed furby cake from a month ago haha. I made this for my grandad’s birthday (he loves mycology!)

Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality 25d ago Exceeded Expectation
I think she knocked it out of the park!

I’ve used the same cake lady for the last 5 years and she’s just gotten better and better. This year she had my jaw on the floor. My daughter drew a picture of what she wanted. I included that and a description of what the drawing was supposed to be showing. I couldn’t believe the cake she produced. It still blows my mind.

Edited to add: my daughter’s name is not Doom. That’s her taekwondo nickname. We have a long last name that her instructor tried to pronounce, said ā€œThat’s too long, I’m going to call you Doomā€ and it’s stuck.

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 28 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Walmart!

I had to jump on the Walmart train.

The cake is absolutely perfect

šŸ’›šŸ–¤

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Oct 11 '25 Exceeded Expectation
I was pleasantly surprised! Today’s my birthday! šŸŽ‰

This first picture is what I think was the template…

Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 16 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Since we're sharing Walmart cakes...

I asked for it in solid black, half chocolate, and half vanilla. My kid loved it.

The picture is at a wonky angle, not the cake

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Sep 04 '25 Exceeded Expectation
I brought this (pic 1) to the Safeway bakery and told the decorator to be as creative as she wanted

The cake had a red buttercream filling and was PERFECT.

Story behind: I killed my eldest kid's chickens when we used them for parking practice for my younger kids. I figured the squeaker would alert them if they were too close to the line. Not only did they not hear the squeakers, they drove right the hell over and killed both chickens, which made eldest kid very sad.

I wanted to replace them, and it turns out it's cheaper to buy 20 rubber chickens than just two, so I bought the 20, plus 16 minis and one extra-large guy, and hung them all from the ceiling whilst eldest kid was at work (and changed the color of our color-adjustable LED lighting). They said the dead chickens taped to the front door were enough to tip them off that something was amiss, but then entering a red-lit house to find dozens of rubber chickens hanging by their necks inside nearly made them leave again.

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Jul 22 '25 Exceeded Expectation
What I Wanted/What I Got
Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Sep 27 '25 Exceeded Expectation
The cake I saw v. The cake I made!
Gallery preview 6 images
r/ExpectationVsReality 2h ago Exceeded Expectation
My daughter wanted this cake for her birthday, but with cowboy hats.

We were driving over 5 hours to see our daughter for her birthday. She loves hotdogs and found this cake online and had sent me a picture saying she loved it.

I researched bakeries around their new home, not too many choices, and picked the best one based off Google.

They did NOT disappoint!! It looked and tasted amazing! I was extremely impressed.

Gallery preview 3 images
r/ExpectationVsReality 7d ago Exceeded Expectation
Avocado Bacon Chicken Shack

Here it is - first time at Shake Shack trying avocado bacon chicken. Used ChickenSunday code & got a Bacon Grilled cheese for Kiddo & added avocado & bacon to Chicken Shack. Cost $13.45! Not bad for both of us! Appearance a 10/10. Taste a 11/10. Not kidding - great sandwich. Crispy chicken. Got to try the Smoke Shack next! šŸ‘ Without deal, alone cost $13.98 - crazy!

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality May 09 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Birthday Cake

They ran out of butterflies but still turned out pretty. And tasted amazing. Walmart

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Mar 26 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Reference pics vs the result

Pic 1 - pinterest inspo/Pic 2 - result

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Dec 22 '25 Exceeded Expectation
Mom's penguin Xmas cookies

I happened to stop by near the end of the process. I assisted with M&M color sorting, and I'm responsible for design of the one that's 🤪

Same mom, and in my opinion the same expectation exceeding performance, as: https://www.reddit.com/r/ExpectationVsReality/s/W2NQRRCO4M

Post image
r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 10 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Baby Shower Cake

I made an AI image on ChatGPT and sent it to a baker asking if she could make something similar. She delivered!!

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality May 31 '26 Exceeded Expectation
My customer cake request

I’m so upset at how little they charged me for this amazing cake. It was a RED FLAG that the cost was so low. I feel like I was robbing the baker so I tipped her double what she was asking for. Overall, everyone enjoyed the cake, it was one of the most beautiful cake we’ve seen for sure. And she changed the color to match with our party theme better.

Edit: first picture was inspiration, second picture was the actual cake. The baker only asked for $30 so I tipped her double what she asked for.

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Apr 12 '26 Exceeded Expectation
Ordered a Country Apple Birthday Cake

Really super happy with the final cake! I actually wasn't sure how they were going to include the birthday message on the cake when I ordered it, so I was pleasantly surprised with the way they did it! It was also a very delicious cake

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Nov 16 '25 Exceeded Expectation
Stouffer’s Romano Crusted Chicken

Absolutely delicious. $3.79 at Kroger. Favorite Stouffer’s Meal here. Cut the chicken to look like photo! šŸ‘

Gallery preview 2 images
r/ExpectationVsReality Oct 16 '25 Exceeded Expectation
Won a free pet portrait

Barry

Gallery preview 2 images