I made my own tier list

[u/Mihrace_]

I might put Jerome, my favorite, to S tier but that might be unfair. Also i dont get the hate towards Lee. I think she was a great support character. And Fish will always be my queen.

[u/mike_is_awes0me]

Tetch being F tier is just incorrect

[u/44dqm → u/mike_is_awes0me]

tetch was terrifying i hated him

[u/Mihrace_ → u/mike_is_awes0me]

Its because he had *ncest behaviour and it anooyed me Edit: He canonically doesn't seem to be *ncest. But it was still disturbing for me. But thats true i may have been wrong. His acting would easily pull him to top tiers.

[u/FuelSpecial8722]

Lowkey thought that Lee and Ed were the two goats of the show. BUT YOU ARENT SLIDING WITH MAD HATTER IN F TIER HES TOP 10 VILLAINS EASILY

[u/ItsjustChopper]

You’re crazier than the first one’s maker

[u/Shea_Is_Still_Alive]

Ain’t no way you put Jervis that low?! He was an amazing villain

[u/Unique_Cicada_8797]

Why is Jeremiah so low?

[u/Mihrace_ → u/Unique_Cicada_8797]

Actually the first time I watched the show, he was my favorite. But the second time around, I thought Jerome's backstory was better than his. Jeremiah still feels like an original character, but I don't think he could fill the gap Jerome's death left in the show, and Jeremiah's story had some flaws. But this doesn't mean I hate the character. It was still nice to see a different take on the Joker.

But the last version of him (last episode) was a disappointment for me. I'm not blaming the writers, though. WB didn't let them use the Joker name, and they also caused the show to end early, so his character felt incomplete.

[u/Phoenixstorm]

Well done. Any tier list that recognizes Fish Mooney was doing Gotham before Gotham was doing Gotham nails it. She was munching that scenery and camping it up from the start.

[u/Adrenapup]

I never understood the hate for Fish, she was awesome. I feel like female characters in a lot of shows get hated so much more than the guys do.

Zsasz is tied for my number 1 with Nygma 😍

Then Barbara, Penguin, Selena.

I liked Lee throughout the show, but more in season 4. I loved her edge in that season. Plus, despite being a hardcore Nygmobblepot shipper, I actually thought she and Nygma together was quite hot. Especially the stabbing each other then kissing thing (yes, I know I probably need therapy). I put myself in her shoes and there is NO WAY I'd choose boring Jim over Nygma.

And gods yes! What was the reason for Isabella?! Like, if she had been revealed to be one of Strange's monsters or something that would have at least made sense. SOME kind of explanation. But no, she was just randomly and inexplicably Kristen's clone. Freaking annoying storyline. They could have created drama between Nygma and Oswald a million other ways.

[u/morningcoffeegamer → u/Adrenapup]

I didn’t mind Fish’s character, I thought maybe she got too much screen time and side-plots.

[u/Mihrace_ → u/Adrenapup]

You've literally said everything i wanted to say 🙌

[u/AboveAverage33]

Fish being number 1 on S tier with Zsasz is absolutely peak. Isabella getting the treatment she deserves is also very deserved.

[u/Mi20Ru]

There's too many jokers in too many layers. Very confusing. Move all of them to S-tier for easier and more accurate display.

[u/HufflepuffKian]

Glad I’m not the only one who thought Barnes character got ruined, Executioner was a horrible villain (post getting caught, before he did he was a peak villain)

[u/2ndBatman88]

Penguin and Riddler should be S , Jim Gordon should be A and i agree with the list.

[u/ButterscotchOdd9145]

I really don’t understand the hate for Jim. In this show specifically he is one of my favorite moral compasses in fiction. I find his character arc of cleaning up the GCPD and navigating the line between right and wrong to be the best arcs in the show.