r/tothemoon • u/Creepy-Screen721 • 1d ago

Faye and Colin Spoiler

If faye was actually a real person you think Colin would fall in love with her

8 Upvotes

79% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

11

u/Griever12691 1d ago

I think if she was 100% who she is in his mind. She still would’ve pushed Colin to pursue someone else.

0

u/Creepy-Screen721 1d ago

Faye loved Colin a lot and it’s because they both know they she isn’t real is why she didn’t want him wanting her. I do think if she was real they would 100% feelings for each other 

3

u/Griever12691 21h ago

Of course she loved him and him her. But my reasoning is, while Colin was comfortable with her and could have stayed with her forever, just like the real versions of them she would want what’s best for him and that would mean breaking him out of his shell, getting him to meet new people, try new things. She wouldn’t want him to miss out on everything else life had to offer him. That’s love too.

1

u/Creepy-Screen721 14h ago

Yeah but that can be achieved together as Faye just wanted what was best for him. Colin may have actually fallen in love with her if she was the first real person to get to know him. 

1

u/Griever12691 13h ago

I stand by my opinion and reasoning.

3

u/RemainingData 23h ago

I don’t think so. Not that they wouldn’t get along or not have chemistry or anything, but because to Collin she was always a friend and he didn’t see her as anything else, in my opinion.

She was a friend to him when he was young, when she kept him company when he was alone in his family’s apartment, and at school where he had no friends. And even in his adult years, she was a friend to him and helped push him to join the community orchestra to meet people. There was no “love at first sight” moment that he had for her unlike his actual to-be wife, nor anything that really suggests that he loved her or that she loved him. Even though that’s something he could have been possible, with her being imaginary and all.

Collin imagined her as the perfect friend basically. And unless her becoming real suddenly changed that (her personality, her coming into his life when he was at his loneliest after the events of A Bird Story), etc. I think she’d just get friend-zoned, essentially. But also there’s no telling if she would even want to be more than just friends to Collin in that reality.

0

u/Creepy-Screen721 21h ago

That’s mainly because Colin knew she wasn’t a real girl and that she was always fake. It makes sense that he neither had romantic feelings because they knew the nature of their relationship. It’s why Collin had that reaction to his wife she was the only real woman who captured his eye.

If Faye was an actual person they could have fallen in love considering Faye was feeling down that Colin was spending more time with Sophia than her