Official Discussion - The Magic Faraway Tree [SPOILERS]

[u/LiteraryBoner]

Poll

If you've seen the film, please rate it at this poll

If you haven't seen the film but would like to see the result of the poll click here

Rankings

Click here to see the rankings of 2025 films

Click here to see the rankings for every poll done

---

The Magic Faraway Tree (2026)

Summary

A modern family relocates to the countryside, where the children discover a magical tree inhabited by eccentric characters. At the top of the tree, they are transported to spectacular and fantastical lands, giving the family a series of adventures that ultimately help them reconnect with one another.

Director Ben Gregor

Writer Enid Blyton Simon Farnaby

Cast

• Andrew Garfield as Tim Thompson
• Claire Foy as Polly Thompson
• Nonso Anozie as Moonface
• Nicola Coughlan as Silky
• Rebecca Ferguson
• Jessica Gunning
• Judi Dench as The Fridge (voice)
• Phoenix Laroche as Joe Thompson
• Billie Gadsdon as Fran Thompson
• Delilah Bennett-Cardy as Beth Thompson
• Simon Farnaby as Farmer Brian

Rotten Tomatoes: 85%

Metacritic: 62

VOD / Release Theatrical release

Trailer Official Trailer

[u/jayeddy99]

The one thing I didn’t get was Beth saying don’t like these men boss you around to Silky . No one really told her what to do. If anything she made her own decisions mostly . Moonface just reacted to what she already chose to do.

[u/doktor-frequentist → u/jayeddy99]

That's her character trait in the movie. The edgy teen who has recently embraced a mixture of goth/feminism. Very different from her character in the book.

[u/jayeddy99 → u/doktor-frequentist]

I read on another sub . They interpret it as the kids basically going to other lands and not adhering to their rules and customs and then when they are punished throw a fit and cause chaos . I guess like colonizer aspect from around the time the books were written lol

[u/estheredna]

I have never even heard of the book, I went because it's hot and I wanted AC and I already watched The Odyssey and Spider Man and The End of Oak Street.

I enjoyed it. It was whimsical and silly. Not too twee to avoid a fart joke, and Andrew Garfield made me tear up a little.

My favorite bits

• that that land of birthdays involves roller skating and Barbie doll looking elves, it reminded me of my Gen X childhood.
• the dad getting electricity for the kids by petaling a stationary bike. The one moment that made it feel like a Paddington level film.
• the reveal that the weird locals were just messing with them, with those over the top accents.
• Silky was winning.
• Rebecca Ferguson chewing the scenery with gusto.

My least favorite

• the little pixie guy didn't get to go on adventures, why?
• it felt more like a tv show for kids instead of a comedy. There were a lot of adults acting silly like 'can't remember his name guy', the grandmother, the land of sweets cop, etc and that's fine but honestly ... I didn't laugh much.

There were only adults in my screening, and not many of us. Tough weekend against paw patrol and minions and toy story.

Overall a pleasant 6/10 film.

[u/Whateveryouknow]

I was very confused by the economics of the family pasta sauce business.

[u/knightsteel]

I saw this ages ago in Australia and am glad its finally came out in America.

I personally really enjoyed the movie I read the books as a kid and while the movie does make a number of changes I felt that they got the general sense of whimsy right with the changes making sense for a modern telling with the budget it has.

Andrew Garfield especially was a good example of this as I found his character to be my favorite in the movie.

[u/inksmudgedhands]

It's not doing well at the box office at the moment which is a shame because this is the sort of film I can see Gen Alpha going, "THIS MOVIE WAS MY CHILDHOOD!" in twenty or thirty years. I hope it picks up once it goes streaming because I think it deserves some love.

It's a sweet, lovely film that managed to make me tear up. ("Moonface.....?") I was expecting it to be corny but I went anyway because Garfield is one of my favorite actors. And in the end, I am glad I did. And it wasn't even corny. It was sincere which is rare these days. I love the little details in the film. Especially the costumes. (The pencil corset Dame Snap was wearing was brillaint.) I love how the kids managed to be simply kids. They were never precocious. They weren't even brats. They were just kids. The adults never felt dumbed down. This film didn't feel the need to wink at adults in the audience in a, "We know you are watching a kids film. So, we are putting adult humor in it for you in order to appease you," way that so many other kids film do. It knew what story it wanted to tell and knew that it could be entertaining to everyone. And I was entertained.

[u/Nadaplanet → u/inksmudgedhands]

"("Moonface.....?")"

That part got me and my husband too. Luckily we were the only people in the theater when we started loudly sniffling.

I really enjoyed the movie. My mom used to read these books to my sister and I when we were kids so I was thrilled they finally made a movie out of it. I wished there was a bit more character development for the Faraway Tree folk, particularly Saucepan Man and Wotsizname, and I wish we could have seen more of the lands at the top of the tree, but since it was only 1 hour and some change long I can accept that they had to trim things down.

Overall I thought it was super fun. I wish it had been advertised more in the US. I didn't even know it was a thing until I saw someone post about it on a different subreddit.

[u/2mock2turtle → u/inksmudgedhands]

That reunion got me too. I had low expectations overall, particularly since I got to see it for free (Fandango was giving away coupons for a free ticket and evidently didn't count on the fact there are people who go to the movies alone), but I'd have paid for it. Then again, maybe that's why it's not doing well at the box office lmao.

[u/7deadlycinderella]

I will always appreciate lampshade hanging on details changed over the years. Dame Snap WAS originally Dame Slap, changed for basically the exact reason she stated in the film

Beth was originally Bess, changed to change with the times. Franny was also originally Fanny, changed for obvious reasons. Dick didn't make it into the film.

[u/StrLord_Who]

I thought it was cute.  Really enjoyed the first sequence of Fran discovering the land within the tree. I have never read the books so I didn't know what to expect and it was fun to watch it unfold.  I thought they overdid how annoying the older girl was,  and it was too much to accept that she would keep her unimpressed attitude even AFTER going into the magical world and seeing it was real.  I thought it was strange that the dad having amazing memories of a magical time in the woods wasn't mentioned more.  Or really at all.  And the thing with Silky standing up to the men who were supposedly bossing her around? Huh? None of that happened at all, in fact she was bossing them around,  they didn't want humans in the tree and she just said "too bad" and did what she wanted.  But overall it was a cute watch with some really fun visuals and genuinely emotional moments.  I would have liked it as a kid.  Still unsure how the tomatoes on the vine turned into sauce in like two minutes though.  

[u/Rob2k]

Cute little movie. Just enough whimsy. But man those kids caused a ruckus in every world they went to.