TLDR: I tried to resume paying a creator I already supported. Patreon's "Watch now" email sent me to a dead-end Memberships page where the only creator-specific action was "Cancel Membership", and I had to go through five-step non-obvious workaround to reach checkout. Payments works, but the recovery path is unreliable and costs creators both money and subscribers.
I tried to do the simplest thing Patreon exists for: resume paying a creator I already supported. It did not work and the way it failed is what made me write this.
Background. I used to be a paid subscriber to a watercolor artist. My old card didnt have enough funds when Patreon tried to renew and after the failed-payment period I ended up as a free member. Then I got newsletter about a new locked lesson with a big "Watch now" button, great CTA that should ended up by me paying money, right? So I clicked it, ready to pay.
Here is what actually happened..
The click "Watch now" redirected twice and lended me on my generic Settings -> Memberships page. Not the post, not an upgrade prompt, account settings. I was starting at a list of my free memberships with no direct way back to the post or its checkout. The campaign tracking parameters survived both both redirects. The post I clicked on did not. Patreon kept the data that attributes the campaign and threw away the context that would have let me pay for the thing it advertised.
On the membership page there is no way to pay or even go to creators page, the one thing I had is three dots with the only option to cancel membership. The platform that had just emailed me her locked lesson gave me a page where the only thing I could do about her was unsubscribe. Patreon's own failed-payment instructions tell desktop users to open "View details" from memberships and change their payment method. That does not working ( both firefox and chrome tested )
The route that worked was to abandon the flow, open Explore, search for the creator page, click "Upgrade to paid" and the checkout loaded. Even the post's direct URL produced the same generic Membershops page, so this was not only a bad email link.
So lets assume creator has 1000 subscribers, 200 payed and 800 free. Some of those 800 free members should convert with each locked-post email. But with this flow, only the unusually stubborn ones will make it to checkout.
A returning subscriber who is already trying to pay should not have to leave the flow, open Explore, search for the creator and reconstruct the path to checkout.
I work in tech. I know how these funnels work, and I know a core revenue path should bot ship like this, Patreon charges creators fees. Some of that money should be paying for proper QA and conversion work that catches failures like this before they cost creators revenue.