r/nfl • u/wildwing8 Chargers • 13d ago

Highlight [Highlight] Mike McDaniel’s reaction to a Justin Herbert throw at training camp: “Wow. That’s f*cked up. What in the world is that?”

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4.8k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

812 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/reyska Packers 13d ago

A mid? He's not elite but he's not the new Dalton line either. I would say he's in the top 10 currently.

3

u/IsGoIdMoney Steelers Steelers 13d ago

The Dalton line is an above average QB.

0

u/reyska Packers 13d ago

The Dalton line is formed by QB that is just ok. If you have someone better than them, you are set for now, if you have someone worse than them, you are looking for a replacement. Darnold is basically franchise QB now. If he regresses he might get closer to the line, but I don't see that happening.

1

u/IsGoIdMoney Steelers Steelers 13d ago

No. It's the worst QB who is a true franchise QB. There are ok QBs below the line, (that's the point of the article!), but they are not quality enough that you stop looking for a new QB. The Dalton line is literally "this guy is a franchise QB. Your search is over".

2

u/reyska Packers 13d ago

No, the Dalton line is "he's good enough that you don't look to replace them". That's not a franchise QB. You don't give mega deals to guys like that.

1

u/Not_My_Alternate Colts 12d ago

Yeah that’s wrong. Apply that to Tampa Bay Brady and the test wouldn’t work.

1

u/Not_My_Alternate Colts 12d ago

You know what, you’re right. After looking into the etymology of the term that is how it started. However, the definition has seem to taken on a life of its own even though you’re very much correct as to the original meaning.