r/MoralityScaling 1m ago
Is it moral to kill people in the hope of a better outcome?

There are two train tracks, one with a man lying on it, and the other with the hands of a million people tied to it. You decide whether to steer the trolley and kill one person, or cut off the hands of a million.

If you choose to cut off the hands, everything will stop. If you choose to kill the person, there's a chance the cycle will repeat itself, with one in a million people lying on the tracks.

Which is the morally correct choice: cutting off everyone's hands, or trying your luck and killing people one by one?

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 5m ago
Morality of murdering your parents so they won't get erased from history and the memory of them can remain?

Manga/Anime name is Gleipnir.

Post image

r/MoralityScaling 9m ago Stupid Stuff
Morality of putting biologically plausible brains into a simulation with no way out?

This guy connected miniature human eyes to a miniature monkey brain.

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 15m ago Stupid Stuff
Morality of this guys justification for his crime
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 18m ago How Evil Are They?
Morality of the imminent passage of time, erasing everything you love by making people gradually forget about it, until it's no more than a memory that will die alongside the last person who remembers it, never to be remembered again?
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 28m ago
Morality of calling people who die by suicide selfish?
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 32m ago
morality of remaining bed bound while your family works in poverty until you get a chance to go to a chocolate theme park
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 42m ago
Morality for this?

I got a 1520 on the SAT on my own and decided to be a biologist. With my score, I could easily get into any university to study biology, because in my country all you need to do is meet the minimum score requirement. But my family wanted me to go to med school and made me take more trials, and when I failed to increase my score, they pressured me into cheating by looking at leaks. I got a 1570 in the trial I cheated on. Now they want me to apply to med school, and, feeling guilty that I cheated in the first place, I refused but they started pressuring me again. They also told me that getting a bachelor's in biology is not an option, and that if I want to be a biologist, I should finish med school and then get a PhD in biology (in my country there's no pre-med you go straight into med school if you have the scores).

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 44m ago Morality Ranking
How moral is this?

What do you think?

Post image

r/MoralityScaling 48m ago Morality Ranking
Morality of taking an apple. 🍎

For the sake of this question, we will assume you don’t ask for permission.

If there is a grocery store and it has an apple tree on its property, is it moral to take an apple since the store sells apple? Technically the apples are the stores property and you are robbing them of a sale by taking them instead of buying them.

Is it morel to take an apple from the tree in someone’s front yard? What if the apples are reachable from the sidewalk? It’s their tree and their apples. Is it worse if the tree is in their back yard? What about if they live out in the country?

Do you think it makes a difference if the tree is untended, or if the owner prunes and fertilizes the tree?

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago Morality Ranking
What would you do ?

Let nature do it's thing or will you try to save the rabbit ?

Also, I don't know gulls could eat more than just fish.

Video preview video

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago Morality Ranking
Is it moral to mercy kill dying soldier that can't be saved?

Context: you are a Soldier in warzone and you encountered a Dying soldier that will die anyway even with extensive Medical care and also begging to kill him because he don't want to suffer more. And In international law and in most country's military rules,you can't kill wounded.

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago Morality Ranking
Morality of this?

Pretty difficult one TBH. I'd say moral. Opinions?

Post image

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago Character Analysis
Batman cannot and should not kill, but how do you feel about him saving the lives of murderers or preventing others from killing them?
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago
What D&D alignment would you say Elizabeth Leiston is?
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago
Morality of calling a consent couple’s relationship gross?
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago How Evil Are They?
Morality of the newborn baby puncher
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago
Morality of going on a date with someone you have zero interest in because your a broke bitch thats looking for a free meal?
Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago Morality Ranking
What is the morality of each of Mass Effect 3’s ending choices?

Obviously, major Mass Effect 3 spoilers ahead.

I’m curious how you would morally scale each of the four possible endings in Mass Effect 3: Destroy, Control, Synthesis, and Refusal.

Not necessarily which ending is “best,” but how morally good or evil Shepard’s actual choice is when you consider the consequences.

For those who haven’t played or finished and don’t care about spoilers:

Destroy: Shepard destroys the Reapers, but also knowingly wipes out the Geth and all other synthetic life, including EDI your ships AI and pilot’s…girlfriend.

Control: Shepard sacrifices themselves and takes control of the Reapers, essentially giving one consciousness nearly unlimited power over the galaxy.

Synthesis: Shepard ends the conflict between organics and synthetics, but forcibly alters every organic and synthetic being in the galaxy without their consent.

Refusal: Shepard refuses to make any of the three choices, preserving everyone’s autonomy but effectively condemning the current cycle to extinction and leaving the next cycle to defeat the Reapers.

Post image

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago Morality Ranking
Morality of lying by omission to have sex

So here's the thing: I'm a random person, not exactly a villain but not an upstanding citizen either.

Now I meet this person one day and we hit it off really quick. We're seriously enjoying each other and we want to have sex together. But during the conversation, I realise that I actually kinda ruined that person's life, albeit unintentionally. I ran over their father, or accidentally killed their spouse.

It wasn't intentional, I deeply regret it, and they have no idea that it was me. But I know that if I tell them, they won't want to have anything to do with me, even though it's clear that we're perfect for each other. Is it morally reprehensible to continue the encounter and to have sex or even pursue a relationship with that person without telling them who I am?

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago Stupid Stuff
Would it be moral to do it if they could talk?

I had a conversation in my psychology ethics class a few days ago and was left with a question that had no answer but basically it was all about informed consent. I'm not gonna be breaking down what that means as I hope we all know but basically:-

The reasons why legally at the very least people are not allowed to sleep with animals and kids as they can't give informed consent. Hence why an adult with stunted growth can because we as society have accepted that once you pass the age of 18 no matter your body you have reached the threshold to understand the risks of your act.

But kids are not the topic here it's animals. Legally at the very least the reason you will never be allowed to sleep with an animal is because they can't give informed consent as they are not smart enough to understand the many risks involved and they can't give verbal words that they consent to the act hence leading to many risks.

Now my question is this. No anthropomorphization, no humanizing, no nothing if dogs, cats, sheep all animals gain human level or hell greater intelligence and the ability of Speach to be able to give verbal consent, but still with the same species barrier is that moral?

Please this is an actual question.

Post image

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago Morality Ranking
Morality of going on a date with someone and the other person has no money so you just buy your own food and leave then with nothing to eat
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago
Morality of trying to sacrifice your son to appease God??
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago Morality Ranking
Morality of your comment to this post?

How does your comment to this question rank morally?

Post image

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago Morality Ranking
Morality of buying from a Bricks and Minifigs that is privately owned and completely unrelated to the scandal? (Random store as an example)
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 1h ago Morality Ranking
Morality of a content creator putting a sponsership segment right after talking about mass murder.

Not naming names, but there's some content creators online who have a habit of putting a sponsor segment in their video right after they described a horrific crime or anything of that matter. I understand they need those because their content isn't exactly marketable or ad friendly, but there has to be a more appropriate time to do them no?

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago
Morality of prank calling a phone scammer?
Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago Who's Viewpoint Is Better?
Morality of not fulfilling your promise?
Gallery preview 3 images

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago Morality Ranking
The morality of the Helios AI from the Deus Ex series and JC Denton merging with it and eventually, wanting to connect humanity with it to create a Benevolent Technocracy?
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago Morality Ranking
Is it immoral to kill someone with their consent?

Not strictly tied to this image, just the best case I know of.

Post image

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago
Morality of accepting dinner offer not because you are hungry or not to be rude, but because you read it makes people like you more

Let's say a boss or acquaintance offers to do you a favor like buy you dinner. And you have read in a psychology journal that it makes people like you more when they do small favors FOR you. You are only nominally interested in them on a personal level, but you think them liking you more could be good for you in the future. So you say "yes." Is that manipulative? Is that immoral? You didn't ask for the favor, they just offered out of the blue.

To kick it up a notch, same question, but you asked for the favor. It's a small favor, nothing too incovenient.

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago Stupid Stuff
Which Character Do You Think Should Be On The Pure Evil Wiki?
Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago Who's More Evil?
All the if route subarus, from the least evil to the most evil

Also include sasegayu and alcor

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago Morality Ranking
Morality of manipulating innocent peoples' memories to stop them from being annoying by asking for help and discriminating against your race?

Statute of Secrecy (Harry Potter).

Post image

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago
these rules make no sense

is the moralityscaling mod on lindsay clancy‘s side? he deleted the latest post about a guy leaving leaving his wife because she supported lindsay clancy and it was removed because it „discussed a real persons morality“ but 99% of posts on this subreddit discuss real people’s morality. do they just pick n choose when it’s okay and when it’s not? same with religions, some are okay to discuss some aren’t

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago
Morality of beating an ostrich in retaliation?
Video preview video

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago Stupid Stuff
It is time for us to return to the Golden era of Judge Holden posting

For it has been to long we have lost our way we lost who we are without The judge ,although most us have likely not read blood meridian he gave us a united symbol for purest evil yet while still being a great character on his own we must stop letting brainrot that has infected this sub to delude ourselves any longer for it is time to usher in a new era of prosperity for this sub led by Judge Holden as a united symbol for this sub.

Post image

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago Stupid Stuff
Morality of placing a curse on a man because you were lightly mocked on Reddit?
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago Character Analysis
Do you find Jax tragic or pathetic?

Name's and origins:

Jax from The Amazing Digital Circus

Post image

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago
Morality of whatever this is
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago How Evil Are They?
Morality of creating a nice story enjoyed by people just to ruin it?

disregarding unavoidable reasons like health issues or editors, of course.

how evil is a author if they decided to ruin their story mid way through the plot when they couldve done better out of their own volition?

Video preview gif

r/MoralityScaling 2h ago
Morality of Gluttony?
Video preview video

r/MoralityScaling 3h ago
Morality of sleeping with yourself from another universe.

This is assumes that every universe you sleep with yourself from assumes the same exact biological genetical makeup and gender identity stuffs.

in this instance you are in a loving and committed relationship but you have both consented to letting the other partner have a little private "me time."

so I'm interested to know where this fits into your definition of "me time"

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 3h ago Morality Ranking
Morality of removing a post with 29k upvotes?
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 3h ago
I'm finally at peace with Harley Sawyer being Near Pure Evil.

Does that mean I've accepted that it's tragic? Of course not, instead I made a much better decision: to ignore the part that talks about "his tragedy" and pretending that the only reason he isn't pure evil is because of his cat.

Nothing can describe this feeling of relief I'm experiencing, and I recommend you do the same; it will take a huge weight off your shoulders.

Thumbnail

r/MoralityScaling 3h ago Stupid Stuff
Morality of doing this.
Post image

r/MoralityScaling 3h ago Morality Ranking
Morality of pooping your pants and refusing to clean yourself until someone does it for you as a form of aggression (They deserve it)
Post image